Friday, April 16, 2010

Magazine Preview - The Estrogen Dilemma - NYTimes.com

Wow. Amazing, amazing article on depression, estrogen, hormone replacement therapy, and the Women's Health Initiative Study. Long, but readable, and worth the read. - sm

Magazine Preview - The Estrogen Dilemma - NYTimes.com:

Berry turned out to be right, of course; she wasn’t on the placebo, which the N.I.H. doctors told her when she finished the study. And as she hurried to fill her own patch prescription, she found her gratitude mixed with more than a little frustration. “Why did my primary-care physician give me an antidepressant when I could have had something simple, like estrogen?” she asked. “Why don’t they know?”

We talked about breast cancer, because that is the nightmare illness in nearly all our calculations, for most of us the visual closest to hand. Three of my best friends have endured the full breast-cancer horror show and by now have retired their wigs. All have survived. None had been on hormone replacement. This is information that batters me steadily but not helpfully, like my ex-smoker paternal aunt’s fatal lung cancer and the fact that I’m a lifetime nonsmoker and regular exerciser with extremely good cholesterol levels. How do my lowered risks from one column balance against my question marks over in another column? What to do?


Read article...

0 comments: